The story follows Pepper and Alec Harper, two individuals whose lives intersect in a college setting, leading to a complicated romantic relationship. Pepper, a quirky and clumsy barista, struggles with self-identity and feelings of inadequacy. Alec, a professor, grapples with his own emotions and the implications of their relationship, especially given his relationship with a childhood friend. Their connection is marked by humor, passion, and ultimately, deep emotional turmoil.